Feel-good, protein-dense desserts baked fresh weekly with 15g–28g protein per treat and zero chalky aftertaste. Pick up your weekly fresh bake drops every Saturday and Sunday morning across community gym hubs in Monmouth County, New Jersey.
Protein: 28g | Calories: 245 | Price: $8.88
Teddi Bakes signature protein pudding blends ultra-filtered whey protein, 0% Greek yogurt, and smooth cottage cheese for an extraordinarily rich, creamy texture. Layered with wholesome cookie crumbles and dark chocolate crispies.
Protein: 28g | Calories: 245 | Price: $8.88
Tastes like raw birthday cake batter whipped into light protein pudding cream. Layered with naturally colored rainbow confetti sprinkles for a celebratory crunch.
Protein: 30g | Calories: 240 | Price: $8.00
Rich dark cocoa protein pudding swirled with creamy natural peanut butter. Formulated for maximum muscle recovery with 30g pure protein.
Protein: 30g | Calories: 230 | Price: $8.88
Traditional Italian cannoli cream crafted with sweet part-skim ricotta, mini dark chocolate chips, and crushed homemade tricolor almond rainbow cookies.
Protein: 28g | Calories: 250 | Price: $8.88
Campfire nostalgia in every spoonful. Velvety toasted marshmallow protein cream swirled with real honey graham cracker crumbles and dark chocolate chips.
Protein: 28g | Calories: 235 | Price: $8.88
Ripe bananas whipped into light protein custard with crunchy vanilla wafers folded throughout.
Protein: 28g | Calories: 220 | Price: $8.88
Real pumpkin puree infused with cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and ultra-filtered protein custard.
Protein: 28g | Calories: 240 | Price: $8.88
Roasted California pistachio flavor blended with our signature ultra-filtered whey custard.
Protein: 28g | Calories: 225 | Price: $8.88
Sweet summer orchard peaches folded into rich Madagascar vanilla protein pudding.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 200 | Price: $5.55
A moist, fluffy bakery muffin packed with 18g clean protein from ultra-filtered whey and egg whites. Naturally sweetened with ripe bananas and studded with melted chocolate chips.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 195 | Price: $5.55
Warm cinnamon roll aroma in a high-protein muffin. Made with Vietnamese cinnamon and a touch of brown sugar alternative, delivering 18g protein and only 195 calories.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 195 | Price: $5.55
Bright, fun, and packed with 18g clean protein. A fluffy vanilla sponge loaded with colorful sprinkles that melt into joyful dots throughout.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 205 | Price: $5.55
For true chocolate lovers. Deep Dutch cocoa crumb with dark chocolate chips melted inside. Satisfies decadent brownie cravings with 18g clean protein.
Protein: 17g | Calories: 160 | Price: $5.55
Bright citrus zest paired with sweet juicy blueberries. Ultra-lean profile with only 1g fat and 17g protein.
Protein: 17g | Calories: 165 | Price: $5.55
Wholesome rolled oats baked with antioxidant-rich dark chocolate morsels and topped with gourmet flaky sea salt.
Protein: 17g | Calories: 160 | Price: $4.00
Pure spiced pumpkin harvest muffin baked with absolutely zero fat. Warm autumn spices with 17g clean protein.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 175 | Price: $5.55
Classic New England style blueberry muffin elevated with 18g whey protein and wholesome whole oats.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 210 | Price: $5.55
Inspired by monster cookies! Hearty whole rolled oats, chocolate chunks, and colorful candy gems in an 18g protein muffin.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 190 | Price: $5.55
Two bakery favorites united. Rich spiced pumpkin muffin batter swirled with a sweet cream cheese protein ribbon.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 185 | Price: $5.55
Rich red velvet cocoa sponge baked with buttermilk flavor and topped with protein cream drizzle.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 190 | Price: $5.55
Naturally sweet shredded carrots folded with warm nutmeg and cinnamon, finished with a luscious protein cream cheese center.
Protein: 18g | Calories: 185 | Price: $5.55
Fragrant roasted pistachio essence folded into a wholesome oat protein muffin.
Protein: 16g | Calories: 185 | Price: $5.55
The best of both worlds. Rich chocolate fudge brownie layered with real chocolate chip cookie dough enhanced with 16g clean whey protein.
Protein: 10g | Calories: 145 | Price: $5.55
Crisp fruity cereal held together with gooey marshmallow protein cream. Only 5g fat, 15g carbs, and 10g protein.
Protein: 12g | Calories: 160 | Price: $5.55
Satisfying peanut butter crunch smothered in a silky layer of dark chocolate protein fudge.
Protein: 20g | Calories: 220 | Price: $7.77
Warm, fragrant protein banana bread baked with ripe bananas, rolled oats, and rich chocolate chips. Provides 20g muscle-repairing protein per hearty slice.
Customize your weekly fitness fuel with our signature 4-pack dessert bundle. Mix and match between 12 velvety Protein Pudding flavors (25g–28g protein) and 8 bakery-fresh Protein Muffins (18g protein). Perfect for pre-workout energy, post-training muscle recovery, and guilt-free late-night dessert satisfaction.
Teddi Bakes was created out of pure frustration with standard fitness snacks. For years, active individuals and athletes in New Jersey had to choose between chalky, artificial protein bars with chemical aftertastes or sugary coffee shop pastries that completely derail daily nutritional goals.
Teddi set out to reinvent high-protein baking using culinary confectionery techniques. By whipping 0% fat Greek yogurt, slow-cultured smooth cottage cheese, and ultra-pure whey protein isolate with real crushed cookies, Belgian speculoos, and dark chocolate, she created an artisanal dessert that delivers 25g–28g of muscle-building protein while tasting like pure, decadent bakery joy.
Orders are baked fresh every Friday and dropped off chilled to our partner fitness centers on Saturday mornings (8:00 AM – 12:00 PM) and Sunday mornings.
“Post-Leg Day 28g Protein Reward. Silky custard texture with zero chalky protein powder taste.”
“18g Protein & under 200 cals! Finally a real bakery muffin that fits my macros.”
“Our members love picking up their fresh Teddi Bakes drop at Paramount Gym every Saturday morning.”